Taking the X Out of Christmas
Last year I wrote "Xmas" instead of "Christmas" on my blog and didn't think much about it at the time. However, a man caught me in the hall at church and expressed some deep disappointment in my sacrilegious language–taking "Christ" out of "Christmas."
For those who have had the same concern, you might find this article, by R.C. Sproul, interesting:
The simple answer to your question is that the X in Christmas is used like the R
in R.C. My given name at birth was Robert Charles, although before I
was even taken home from the hospital my parents called me by my
initials, R.C., and nobody seems to be too scandalized by that.X can mean so many things. For example, when we want to denote an unknown quantity, we use the symbol X.
It can refer to an obscene level of films, something that is X-rated.
People seem to express chagrin about seeing Christ's name dropped and
replaced by this symbol for an unknown quantity X. Every year
you see the signs and the bumper stickers saying, "Put Christ back into
Christmas" as a response to this substitution of the letter X for the name of Christ.First of all, you have to understand that it is not the letter X that is put into Christmas. We see the English letter X there, but actually what it involves is the first letter of the Greek name for Christ. Christos is the New Testament Greek for Christ. The first letter of the Greek word Christos is transliterated into our alphabet as an X. That X has come through church history to be a shorthand symbol for the name of Christ.
We don't see people protesting the use of the Greek letter theta, which is an O with a line across the middle. We use that as a shorthand abbreviation for God because it is the first letter of the word Theos, the Greek word for God.
The idea of X
as an abbreviation for the name of Christ came into use in our culture
with no intent to show any disrespect for Jesus. The church has used
the symbol of the fish historically because it is an acronym. Fish in Greek (ichthus)
involved the use of the first letters for the Greek phrase "Jesus
Christ, Son of God, Savior." So the early Christians would take the
first letter of those words and put those letters together to spell the
Greek word for fish. That's how the symbol of the fish became the
universal symbol of Christendom. There's a long and sacred history of
the use of X to symbolize the name of Christ, and from its origin, it has meant no disrespect.Taken from Now, That's a Good Question!
©1996 by R.C. Sproul. Used by permission of Tyndale on the blog of Ligonier Ministries.
Did this article change your mind at all?
Posted by Tim Stevens | 24 comments









Larry Shallenberger
The X is from Xristos, the Greek spelling of Christ. Any sacrilege comes from the attitude of the writer.
Good Xian Men Rejoice,
With Heart and Soul and Voice!
David Whiting
When I am writing things for myself I shorten "Christmas" to "Xmas" and "Christ" to "X" – but I've experienced what you have – being accused of all kinds of things when I do it publicly.
So – in considering the weaker brother or sister (1 Corinthians 8:9-13) – I avoid doing it publicly unless I also explain why I do it (as you have here). But then I feel like I spend way too much time explaining it.
Jermtech
Tim, you were a lot more tactful, patient, and far less sarcastic than I was with this topic
http://jermination.wordpress.com/2008/12/05/merry…
Bill (cycleguy)
IMHO I think people get bent out of shape over a lot of things…much of them small and insignificant. This is one of them. I personally don't think Jesus is the Reason for the Season as it says. I believe He is the meaning and we are the reason. But I don't make bumper stickers and protest what I deem to be misinformed. Neither do I with Xmas. But having R.C.'s explanation sure helps explain things to naysayers. Thanks for this post Tim.
haydee
No, the article didn't change my mind. Seriously, the people I know who spell Xmas are non-followers, some people who are lazy to write Christmas & few "Christians" who are not passionate with Jesus.. but those who love the Lord so much, myself included at least gives respect not to take away the Christ from Christmas.
JB
Not really! I already knew the connection with the Greek translation of X but many people don’t. For them and still for me it is offensive to replace what we recognize obviously as meaning "Christ" for His birthday with the convenient "X". It just seems that in so many areas of life Christ is being taken out so why not proclaim Him in a way people get. I think in most peoples minds it the same as replacing a Christmas party with a holiday party – but that’s just me!
jamesmcoats@gmail.co
I was fine with it's usage but seeing the article from R.C. provides me some actual logic to support my being fine with it
EdgarCabello
No problem here. I think our expectations on our culture to pacify our fears of losing control are so strange especially when Jesus makes it plain through the scriptures that we will be considered 'outsiders' along with him in culture. We are exiles in a foreign land; citizens of another 'kingdom'.
Pat
No one seems to be up in arms about not calling him Jesus of Nazereth, are they? Most people don't even realize what Christ means, thinking it is a name and not a title
Brad Goode
Even thought a long time ago people used the word Gay to mean happy, we no longer say so and so had a gay time. Culture had re-defined what that word means. In the same way i think culture has redefined the X from the Greek Letter to a way to remove Christ.
It's defiantly not a hill to die on. Outside of RC and some of his die hards nobody see's X-mas and thinks greek.
I couldn't agree with David above more!
www.facebook.com/pro
We actually did a series last year entitled, XMAS: where did He go?
The big idea was He has always been here, find Christ in your every day world.
It connected for some and ticked off others. Oh well…lol
It was a fun series
missional girl
My best friend and I just had a discussion about this and I explained the history behind the Greek symbol. I only wish that some of the same Christians I've come across who would argue me down about the matter would demonstrate as much passion about living for Jesus on a daily basis. That said, David's advice is best and any way we can avoid needless conflict is a plus.
Rick Johnson
Tim, to accuse you as a Christian pastor of removing Christ from Christmas is an uncharitable judgment. Perhaps culture has redefined the abbreviation "X-mas" or maybe it more similar to the "Mrs. vs "Miss" vs "Ms" thing with a few people taking offense at what is not meant to give offense.
Personally, I have more problems with the whole "Happy Holidays" phrase, holiday trees and winter break at school instead of Christmas break because that is meant to downplay the sacredness of Christmas as the celebration of the birth of Jesus the Christ.
joe costigan
you hit it on the nose, come on people like it is so hard to spell christmas give me a break. as christians there are not many times a year you get to write the name of christ, so stop being lazy or making excuses.
blenderzen@gmail.com
unbelievable, i hope that these people who get "up in arms" about semantics are as readily available when it comes to serving the Gospel and doing "for the least of these", and instead of finding a new cause (that means little to nothing to the lost and dying that surround us on a daily basis) to rally behind, actually start living lives that are full of the passion and power of the Living God they claim.
Cora Llamas
Yes it did, that piece from R.C. Sproul helped a lot. Personally, I'm not that strict about the X in X'mas but I can understand the folks who feel that our Christian culture is fast giving in to secularism and therefore they feel more defensive. This short explanation should help lower everyone's guard a bit, I think.
Cora Llamas
As an afterthought…I'd have to agree with one brother here who said he had more issues with "Happy Holidays." Again I can understand the inclusion of everyone in the spirit of goodwill, but not to the point of forgetting why we celebrate the holidays in the first place.
I live in the Third World that doesn't have as much comfort as the more developed countries. But one thing I am grateful for are the "small things"…like we can celebrate the Roman Catholic Mass or the Protestant service during Christmas in very public places like the malls. Or display the Christian nativity scene in those same venues – and nobody would raise a rant about offending public sensibilities.
Dan
What gets me is how about keeping Christ in ALL of life, the other 364 days of the year? Jesus is not the reason for the season, Jesus is our reason for the life that we live. I don't see these people getting as passionate about proclaiming Christ the rest of the year.
Robert Hall
Haydee and Joe Costigan said people who didn't write "Christ" were lazy and not passionate about Jesus.
Well, ok. The original text the new testament was written in as Aramaic and Greek. Have you learned those languages? Oh c'mon people! Are you so lazy that someone had to translate it into English? Were you too lazy to learn Greek?
An labhraíonn tú Gaeilge, an tUasal Costigan? You don't speak Gaelic do you Mr. Costigan? C'mon man, you can't speak your own ancestral tongue?
This is of course all tongue in cheek. The point I am making is that people's ignorance and assuptions based on their own cultural upbringing leads to false ideas based on nonsense. It is only in the Protestant denominations here in American that we find such ignorance of history, language and culture and the prevalence of ideas such as these.
Y'shua ben Yosef, Iasus Cristos, Jesus of Nazareth, it's all the same name.
Lee Dempsey
I think…. much ado. I am a Christian, my neighbor is Hindu. He doesn't expect me to say happy Diwalli unless I convert to his theology. Not going to happen. I don't expect the World to revere the name of Christ. Splitting hairs about the name is not useful. I don't speak Greek.
I enjoy Granger over here in NJ.
Tom Becker
I can see both sides of this. Probably the best thing to have done Tim was to just tell the guy who berated you about the X-mas thing "I'm sorry,(even if he's wrong) you're right, I'll use Christ from now on." You probably did say something to that effect because you seem very humble. But then you had to defend yourself with that article which may have been true but I would've just left it alone. We don't always have to be right even if we are or think we are.
Jesse
I agree with Rick…
The X no more takes Christ out of Christmas for believers than making sure that Christ is in the word makes the Saviors birth meaningful to pagans. I don't think anyone ever sees the word X-mas and thinks, "Gee I wonder what X mas is…does it stand for something?" It's even possible that, given mans desire to see things as complete, that more people think about the word Christ when the see the X than they do when they see the word Christmas.
As Rick said above, the real effort to take Christ out of Christmas is in removing any thought about his birth – "Have a happy holiday as you enjoy your winter break."
If we spent half as much time proclaiming what God has done for us as we do bickering about abbreviations, what we sing or what our brothers and sisters wear to church we'd be far more affective for the Kingdom.
Tom Becker
So all this bickering could be avoided if Tim would've just did what was suggested and never brought it up on this blog for debate. ??????
DC Curry
Let's not completely write this off as mere bickering. It's clear that there are at least a few people who were helped by this blog post.
There is nothing wrong with a little disagreement from time to time, sometimes it's really healthy, much like in this case. There are a few people here who have identified themselves as having a more solid foundation as to where they will stand regarding this issue and that's a good thing. Praise God for that!
Without people challenging our thought patterns and beliefs from time to time, we have the potential to lose the conviction that deepens and strengthens our faith. (in example Jesus' temptations after returning from the wilderness. He was challenged to stand on what He believed rather than avoid the conflict with Satan.)
To each his own, but it's great to celebrate the strength and clarity found in Christ through the perspective of this dialog. Godspeed!